Skip to Content

How To Choose The Best Cut Of Beef For Your Next Bbq

How To Choose The Best Cut Of Beef For Your Next Bbq

There’s nothing like firing up the grill, and when the intoxicating aroma of smoky charred meat fills the air, I can’t help but feel a sense of anticipation.

My friends and family gather around, eagerly awaiting their first bites of deliciously tender beef. But what makes this barbecue special isn’t just the company or the mouthwatering scent – it knows that I’ve chosen the absolute best cut of beef for our feast.

Navigating different cuts of beef can be overwhelming, especially when trying to find that perfect selection for your next cookout.

Whether you’re an experienced grill master or a novice backyard barbecuer, understanding beef cuts and grading is important in ensuring your guests leave with satisfied taste buds.

You don’t want to serve up dry, overcooked leather, do you?

Want some grilling techniques for different beef cuts ? Check my guide out.

In this article, we’ll explore various options like Ribeye, New York strip, filet mignon, T-bone, and Porterhouse steaks – discussing their unique flavors and textures along with tips for grilling success so you can confidently choose the ideal cut for your next BBQ extravaganza.

Understanding Beef Cuts and Grading

Understanding Beef Cuts and Grading

To make your grilling experience top-notch, it’s essential to understand beef cuts and grading. Beef marbling basics are fundamental in choosing the best cut, as marbling refers to the fat distribution within the meat.

The more evenly distributed the fat is, the more tender and flavorful your steak will be.

There are three main grades of beef: prime, choice, and select. Prime cuts have the highest amount of marbling, making them perfect for grilling due to their tenderness and juiciness.

Selecting prime cuts ensures you get a high-quality piece of meat that will impress your guests with its taste.

When examining different beef cuts at the butcher or grocery store, please take note of their appearance and texture.

Look for a bright red color with creamy white flecks throughout, indicating proper marbling. Additionally, pay attention to the thickness of each cut; thicker steaks typically mean more tenderness when cooked properly on the grill.

Remember that certain cuts may fare better on the barbecue than others – popular choices include Ribeye, strip loin (also known as New York strip), T-bone, Porterhouse, and filet mignon (also called tenderloin).

These prime cuts offer varying degrees of tenderness, but all boast rich flavor profiles guaranteed to satisfy even the most discerning barbecue aficionado.

Ribeye: The Classic Choice

Ribeye the classic choice

You can’t go wrong with a classic ribeye at your upcoming barbecue – it’s tender, juicy, and packed with mouthwatering flavor!

The key to the Ribeye’s deliciousness lies in its marbling, which means those thin veins of fat running throughout the meat.

Ribeye marbling sets this cut apart, as the fat melts during cooking and infuses the steak with that incredible taste and tenderness we crave.

Plus, if you’re looking for an extra touch of decadence, try opting for a bone-in ribeye – not only does it look impressive on the grill, but many believe that cooking with the bone-in adds even more flavor to your steak.

When choosing a ribeye for your next BBQ, watch for those beautiful flecks of white fat evenly distributed throughout the muscle tissue.

This generous marbling indicates that you’ve got a high-quality cut destined for greatness on the grill.

If you’re going all-out with a bone-in option (sometimes referred to as a ‘cowboy’ or ‘tomahawk’ steak), ensure plenty of marbling within that meat near the bone – this will ensure maximum juiciness and tenderness once cooked.

With its rich beefy flavor and melt-in-your-mouth texture, there’s no doubt that a well-marbled ribeye will be an absolute hit at your next backyard barbecue!

New York Strip: A Flavorful Option

New York Strip_ A Flavorful Option

There’s nothing like sinking your teeth into a succulent New York Strip at a summertime cookout, and it’s no surprise that this flavorful cut has legions of fans who swear by its superiority.

The picture that sizzling steak being the talk of the town as you reminisce about that time you dined at an upscale steakhouse and couldn’t help but notice the entire table around you ordering this crowd-pleasing favorite – now, imagine recreating that delectable experience right in your backyard.

The secret lies in choosing the perfect New York Strip for grilling and mastering some cooking techniques to ensure it turns out just right.

When selecting a New York Strip, look for steaks with good marbling (those thin veins of fat running through the meat), which are key to achieving maximum flavor and tenderness.

Experiment with strip steak marinades, such as a simple mix of olive oil, garlic, salt, pepper, or perhaps something bolder like soy sauce, ginger, and brown sugar to enhance its natural taste.

Once marinated for at least 30 minutes (or up to 8 hours), preheat your grill to medium-high heat before placing the steaks directly on the grate.

For optimal results when grilling your New York Strip steaks – aim for an internal temperature range between 130°F (medium-rare) and 145°F (medium).

Use a meat thermometer to check the doneness level without cutting into those gorgeous cuts; you wouldn’t want any precious juices escaping prematurely!

Finally, let those juicy babies rest for about five minutes after they come off the grill so their flavors can meld together perfectly.

With these tips in mind: choose wisely when picking out your next BBQ feast centerpiece – because nothing says summer quite like a mouthwatering grilled New York Strip!

Filet Mignon: Ultimate Tenderness

Filet Mignon_ Ultimate Tenderness

If it’s melt-in-your-mouth tenderness you’re after, look no further than the luxurious filet mignon! This cut of beef is known for its unbeatable tenderness and buttery texture, making it a top choice for any BBQ lover. The filet mignon comes from the small end of the tenderloin, a muscle that does very little work, resulting in an incredibly tender piece of meat.

When cooked properly, this exquisite cut will have your guests raving about your grilling skills.

Filet mignon’s versatility is one of its greatest assets when planning the perfect BBQ menu.

You can enjoy this tender cut in various ways:

  • Grilled: Season with salt and pepper or your favorite rub, then grill to medium-rare perfection.
  • Wrapped in bacon: Add some smoky flavor by wrapping each filet with a slice before grilling.
  • Kabobs: Cube the filets and skewer them with vegetables for a delicious kabob option.
  • Stuffed: Make a slit in each filet and stuff it with cheese or other savory fillings before grilling.
  • Steak sandwiches: Slice-grilled filets and serve on crusty bread with your favorite toppings.

When considering tenderness factors like marbling and muscle usage, there’s no competition – filet mignon takes the crown as the ultimate tender option for your next BBQ.

Its unmatched texture and versatility ensure you’ll serve dishes that satisfy everyone – whether they prefer their steak straight off the grill or dressed up with delectable toppings.

So treat yourself (and your guests) to this indulgent cut at your next backyard gathering!

T-Bone and Porterhouse: Double the Delight

T-Bone and Porterhouse_ Double the Delight

Can’t decide between two delicious steak options?

Fear not, as T-bone and Porterhouse steaks offer double the delight, satisfying even the most discerning taste buds at any cookout. Both cuts come from the short loin section of a cow and feature a T-shaped bone separating two different types of meat – tenderloin on one side and strip steak on the other.

While these steaks may appear similar, subtle differences can help you choose which cut is perfect for your next BBQ.

Let’s look at some T-bone options and Porterhouse comparisons:

T-Bone Steak Porterhouse Steak
Smaller Tenderloin Side Larger Tenderloin Side
More Affordable Option Slightly Pricier Choice
Great for Solo Indulgence Ideal for Sharing or Special Occasions

Let’s now compare and contrast their flavor and nutritional profiles;

  T-Bone Steak Porterhouse Steak
Protein Approximately 28g per 3-ounce serving Approximately 29g per 3-ounce serving
Fat Approximately 18g per 3-ounce serving (includes 7g saturated fat) Approximately 19g per 3-ounce serving (includes 8g saturated fat)
Calories Approximately 210 per 3-ounce serving Approximately 240 per 3-ounce serving
Iron Approximately 15% of the daily recommended intake Approximately 16% of the daily recommended intake
Flavor T-Bone is less marbled than Porterhouse. It is a bit leaner and has a lighter beef flavor. Porterhouse, with more of the tenderloin section, is highly marbled and, therefore, juicier and more flavorful.

As seen in the table above, T-bone steaks have a smaller tenderloin portion than porterhouses, making them an excellent option if you’re craving that signature tenderness but don’t want to break the bank.

On the other hand, porterhouses boast a larger tenderloin side that makes them perfect for sharing or indulging during special occasions.

No matter which cut you decide, T-bone and porterhouse steaks are guaranteed to impress your guests with their juicy flavors and melt-in-your-mouth textures when grilled to perfection.

Tips for Grilling Success

Tips for Grilling Success

Ready to up your grilling game and wow everyone at the cookout with perfectly cooked T-bone or porterhouse steaks? Follow these tips for success, and you’ll have them begging for seconds!

There are a few key aspects to consider regarding grilling techniques.

First, ensure you’ve preheated your grill to high heat (around 450°F) before putting the steaks on. This ensures a nice sear on the outside while keeping the inside juicy and tender.

Once the grill is hot enough, place your seasoned steaks over direct heat and cook them for 3-5 minutes per side, depending on your desired doneness. Remember that porterhouse steaks may require slightly longer cooking times due to their larger size.

Marinating secrets is essential in taking your steaks from good to great.

To achieve maximum flavor impact, marinate your T-bone or porterhouse steak in a simple yet flavorful mixture of olive oil, minced garlic, salt, pepper, and some fresh herbs like rosemary or thyme for at least an hour – but no more than four hours – before grilling.

This infuses the meat with delicious flavors and helps tenderize it further.

Once marinated and ready to hit the grill, be sure not to overcrowd the cooking surface; give each steak room to breathe so it can develop that irresistible crust we crave.

Finally, after removing them from the grill and allowing them a few minutes of rest under tented foil – remember that they will continue cooking during this period – slice against the grain when serving for ultimate tenderness and flavor release in every bite!

My Final Thoughts

In our quest to master the BBQ, we’ve delved into understanding beef cuts and grading systems, which are crucial to making an informed choice.

From the classic Ribeye, known for its marbling and rich flavor, to the tender and elegant Filet Mignon, each cut offers a unique BBQ experience. Don’t forget about the New York Strip’s robust flavor or the T-Bone and Porterhouse cuts that deliver double the delight with their two-in-one feature.

As Aaron Franklin, a renowned pitmaster, says, “Respect the fire, and you’ll get the best BBQ results.” And, according to Beef.

It’s What’s for Dinner, “Grill over medium heat…to ensure even cooking”

May your grilling journey be filled with sizzling success, and remember, choosing the right cut is half the battle.

Sign up for our newsletter for more tips and insights to up your BBQ game.

Together, we’ll make every BBQ a moment to remember.


  1. Franklin, A. (2015). Franklin Barbecue: A Meat-Smoking Manifesto.
  2. Beef. It’s What’s For Dinner. (n.d.)—grilling Basics.